Rice Theorem

Rice theorem states that any non-trivial semantic property of a language which is recognized by a Turing machine is undecidable. A property, P, is the language of all Turing machines that satisfy that property.

Formal Definition

If P is a non-trivial property, and the language holding the property, L_p , is recognized by Turing machine M, then L_p = {<M> | L(M) ∈ P} is undecidable.

Description and Properties

• Property of languages, P, is simply a set of languages. If any language belongs to P (L ∈ P), it is said that L satisfies the property P.

• A property is called to be trivial if either it is not satisfied by any recursively enumerable languages, or if it is satisfied by all recursively enumerable languages.

• A non-trivial property is satisfied by some recursively enumerable languages and are not satisfied by others. Formally speaking, in a non-trivial property, where L ∈ P, both the following properties hold:

  • Property 1 − There exists Turing Machines, M1 and M2 that recognize the same language, i.e. either ( <M1>, <M2> ∈ L ) or ( <M1>,<M2> ∉ L )

  • Property 2 − There exists Turing Machines M1 and M2, where M1 recognizes the language while M2 does not, i.e. <M1> ∈ L and <M2> ∉ L

Proof

Suppose, a property P is non-trivial and ∈ P.

Since, P is non-trivial, at least one language satisfies P, i.e., L(M₀) ∈ P , ∋ Turing Machine M₀.

Let, w be an input in a particular instant and N is a Turing Machine which follows −

On input x

• Run M on w
• If M does not accept (or doesn't halt), then do not accept x (or do not halt)
• If M accepts w then run M₀ on x. If M₀ accepts x, then accept x.

A function that maps an instance ATM = {<M,w>| M accepts input w} to a N such that

• If M accepts w and N accepts the same language as M₀, Then L(M) = L(M₀) ∈ p
• If M does not accept w and N accepts , Then L(N) = ∉ p

Since A_TM is undecidable and it can be reduced to Lp, Lp is also undecidable.