Decision Problems for Automata and Grammars

Quiz

In theory of computation, we have seen several automata and grammars. A Turing Machine (TM) uses recursive enumerable grammars. In recursion theory and computational complexity theory, a decision problem is a yes-or-no question on specified sets of inputs.

Decision problems are important in understanding the capabilities and limitations of computational models such as automata and grammars. Automata and grammars are mathematical models used to define formal languages. Here in this article we will see several decision problems and their details for a clear understanding.

Automata and Decision Problems

Finite automata are simple computational models which is used to recognize regular languages. They have finite number of states, transitions between states, and a set of input symbols.

A finite automaton processes an input string by moving through states according to the input symbols, and it accepts or rejects the string based on its final state.

Decision Problems for Finite Automata

Following are the decision problems for finite automata −

Emptiness Problem − The emptiness problem checks whether the language recognized by a given finite automaton is empty or not, so whether it accepts any strings at all or not. This is a decision problem where the answer is "yes" if the language is empty and "no" otherwise.
Universality Problem − The universality problem checks whether a given finite automaton accepts all possible strings over its input alphabet or not. This problem can also be framed as a decision problem where the answer is "yes" if the automaton accepts every possible string and "no" otherwise.
Equivalence Problem − The equivalence problem for finite automata checks whether two given automata recognize the same language. This is another example of a decision problem where the answer is "yes" if the languages are the same and "no" if they are

Grammars and Decision Problems in Context-Free Grammars

Context-free grammars (CFGs) are used to generate context-free languages. A CFG consists of a set of production rules that describe how strings in the language can be generated from a start symbol.

Decision Problems for Context-Free Grammars

Following are the decision problems for context-free grammars −

Membership Problem − The membership problem checks whether a given string belongs to the language generated by a specific context-free grammar or not. This is a decision problem with the answer "yes" if the string can be generated by the grammar and "no" otherwise.
Emptiness Problem − This is similar to finite automata, the emptiness problem for CFGs checks whether the language generated by the grammar is empty or not. The answer to this decision problem is "yes" if the language is empty and "no" otherwise.
Equivalence Problem − The equivalence problem for CFGs checks whether two grammars generate the same language or not. This problem is more complex than the equivalence problem for finite automata. The answer is "yes" if the languages are identical and "no" if they differ.

Examples of Decision Problems in Automata and Grammars

Go through the following examples to get a better understanding of how decision problems matter in automata and grammars.

Example 1: Membership Problem in Finite Automata

Consider a finite automaton A that recognizes the language of strings over the alphabet {0,1} that end in "01." The decision problem here is to determine whether a given string, say "1101", belongs to the language recognized by A.

Example 2: Emptiness Problem in Context-Free Grammars

Let G be a context-free grammar with production rules that generate strings containing an equal number of 'a's and 'b's. The emptiness problem asks whether G generates any strings at all.

If the production rules are such that no string can be generated (for example, if there is a missing rule to produce 'b'), then the answer to this decision problem is "yes," indicating that the language is empty.

Example 3: Universality Problem in Finite Automata

Consider a finite automaton B that recognizes all strings over the alphabet {0,1}. The universality problem asks whether B accepts every possible string over {0,1}. Since B is designed to accept all strings, the answer to this decision problem is "yes."

Example 4: Equivalence Problem in Context-Free Grammars

Suppose we have two context-free grammars, G₁ and G₂, where G₁ generates strings of balanced parentheses, and G₂ generates strings that match the same pattern but with a different set of production rules.

The equivalence problem asks whether the languages generated by G₁ and G₂ are the same. If both grammars generate identical strings, the answer to this decision problem is "yes". However, if there is any difference, the answer is "no".

Computational Complexity of Decision Problems

Here it categorises decidable decision problems by how difficult they are to solve. "Difficult," in this sense, is described in terms of the computational resources needed by the most efficient algorithm for a certain problem.

For automata and grammars, decision problems are often classified into different complexity classes, such as P, NP, and PSPACE.

Class P − The complexity class P is the set of decision problems that can be solved by a deterministic Turing machine in polynomial time. For example, the membership problem for finite automata is in class P, as it can be solved efficiently.
Class NP − The class NP includes decision problems for which a solution can be verified in polynomial time. Some decision problems for context-free grammars, such as the membership problem, are in NP.
Class PSPACE − The class PSPACE includes decision problems that can be solved using a polynomial amount of memory. Certain decision problems for grammars, like the equivalence problem, may fall into this category due to their complexity.

Undecidable Decision Problems

Some decision problems in the context of automata and grammars are undecidable, so no algorithm can solve them for all possible inputs.

For example, the equivalence problem for context-free grammars is undecidable in general, as there is no algorithm that can determine whether two arbitrary CFGs generate the same language.

Conclusion

In this chapter, we covered the concept of decision problems in automata theory and grammars. They involve yes-or-no questions that determine properties such as language membership, emptiness, and equivalence. We need to understand the decision problems which also help in classifying languages and automata into different complexity classes.

Print Page