Enumerator Turing Machine in Automata Theory

---

---

There are different variations of Turing Machines, which are quite powerful and useful in several cases. We have a variation of the Turing machine called the Enumerator, which plays a different but equally important role. In this type of machine, instead of simply determining whether a string is in a language, an enumerator generates or lists all the strings that belong to a language.

In this chapter, we will see what an enumerator is, how it works, and how it relates to Turing machines, with a focus on examples to illustrate its functionality.

Basics of Enumerator Turing Machine

An Enumerator is similar to a Turing machine in structure but with a distinct purpose.

• Like a Turing machine, an enumerator has a tape that extends infinitely and a finite state control that guides its operations.
• The key difference is that an enumerator also has a printer.
• This printer allows the enumerator to produce strings, effectively generating a sequence of strings that make up a language.

The functional block diagram of the machine is looking like below −

Key Characteristics of Enumerator Turing Machine

Let us see some of the important characteristics of the Enumerator Turing Machine −

• Tape − The tape of an enumerator is initially empty, and unlike a standard Turing machine, there is no input string provided to it.
• Finite State Control − The control unit of an enumerator functions similarly to that of a Turing machine, guiding the machine's operations based on its current state and the symbols on the tape.
• Printer − The printer is a unique feature of the enumerator, enabling it to output strings that belong to the language it is enumerating.
• Operations − The operation of an enumerator is straightforward. It begins with an empty tape and produces strings by writing them onto the tape and then printing them out. The enumerator lists all the strings in a language, effectively defining that language through enumeration.
• Halting and Looping − An enumerator can either halt after producing a certain number of strings or it may continue to loop indefinitely, generating more strings. For infinite languages an enumerator will run forever, printing out an endless list of strings.

How Does an Enumerator Define a Language?

The way an enumerator defines a language is different from how a Turing machine does.

• A Turing machine accepts or rejects individual strings, determining whether each one belongs to the language.
• An enumerator, on the other hand, simply prints out all the strings that are part of the language. It does not reject any strings; instead, it either prints a string (indicating it is part of the language) or does not print it (indicating it is not part of the language).

Duplicates and Order

An important aspect of enumerators is that they are allowed to print duplicate strings. Even if a string is printed multiple times, it is still considered part of the language.

Additionally, the order in which the strings are printed does not matter. The only requirement is that the enumerator must print every string in the language at some point, regardless of the sequence in which they appear.

Relation to Turing Recognizable Languages

We know that a language is Turing recognizable if and only if an enumerator can enumerate it. This means that enumerators have the same computational power as Turing machines when it comes to recognizing languages.

This equivalence is established through a construction that shows how to convert an enumerator into a Turing machine and vice versa.

Example of Constructing a Turing Machine from an Enumerator

Let us see an example on how to make a Turing machine given an enumerator. Suppose we have an enumerator that lists all the strings of a language. We want to build a Turing machine that can recognize this language, meaning it should accept any string that is in the language.

• Running the Enumerator − The Turing machine runs the enumerator as a subroutine. The enumerator begins generating strings.
• Comparing Strings − For every string that the enumerator produces, the Turing machine compares it to the input string (the string it is testing).
• Accepting the Input − If the enumerator prints a string that matches the input string, the Turing machine will accept the input, indicating that it belongs to the language.

Handling Infinite Languages

Since the enumerator might run indefinitely, printing an infinite number of strings, the Turing machine continues to compare each new string until it finds a match or until it decides to stop if the input string is not part of the language.

This method shows how a Turing machine can serve as an enumerator to recognize a language. It shows a close relationship between these two computational models.

Example of Constructing an Enumerator from a Turing Machine

Now let's consider the reverse process; let us construct an enumerator from a Turing machine. Suppose we have a Turing machine that recognizes a language. We want to build an enumerator that lists all the strings in this language.

• Enumerating All Possible Strings − The enumerator first generates all possible strings over a given alphabet. For example, if the alphabet is {0, 1}, it will generate strings like "0", "1", "00", "01", and so on.
• Simulating the Turing Machine − The enumerator runs the Turing machine on each of these strings. For each string, it checks whether the Turing machine accepts it.
• Printing Accepted Strings − If the Turing machine accepts a string, the enumerator prints that string.

Parallel Computation

A challenge arises when the Turing machine might loop indefinitely on some strings. To handle this, the enumerator must simulate the Turing machine on all strings in parallel. This means, the enumerator works on each string for a certain number of steps, then moves on to the next string, and so on.

If the Turing machine accepts a string within the allocated steps, the enumerator prints it. If not, it continues to process other strings, ensuring that no string is left unchecked.

Handling Infinite Loops

If the Turing machine loops indefinitely on some strings, the enumerator still needs to explore other strings. By interleaving the simulations, the enumerator ensures that even if one string causes the Turing machine to loop, it can still find and print other strings that belong to the language.

Conclusion

In this chapter, we explained the concept of Enumerated Turing machine. This type of machine has unique properties over the other variants. It uses pointers and generates strings, then prints when accepts. In this chapter, we presented two conversion strategies with possible hazards related to Enumerated Turing Machines.