Insecure Direct Object References


A direct object reference is likely to occur when a developer exposes a reference to an internal implementation object, such as a file, directory, or database key without any validation mechanism which allows attackers to manipulate these references to access unauthorized data.

Let us understand Threat Agents, Attack Vectors, Security Weakness, Technical Impact and Business Impacts of this flaw with the help of simple diagram.

insecure direct obj ref


The App uses unverified data in a SQL call that is accessing account information.

String sqlquery = "SELECT * FROM useraccounts WHERE account = ?";
PreparedStatement st = connection.prepareStatement(sqlquery, ??);
st.setString( 1, request.getParameter("acct"));
ResultSet results = st.executeQuery( );

The attacker modifies the query parameter in their browser to point to Admin.

Hands ON

Step 1 − Login to Webgoat and navigate to access control flaws Section. The goal is to retrieve the tomcat-users.xml by navigating to the path where it is located. Below is the snapshot of the scenario.

1. insecure direct obj ref1

Step 2 − The path of the file is displayed in 'the current directory is' field - C:\Users\userName$\.extract\webapps\WebGoat\lesson_plans\en and we also know that the tomcat-users.xml file is kept under C:\xampp\tomcat\conf

Step 3 − We need to traverse all the way out of the current directory and navigate from C:\ Drive. We can perform the same by intercepting the traffic using Burp Suite.

2 insecure direct obj ref

Step 4 − If the attempt is successful, it displays the tomcat-users.xml with the message "Congratulations. You have successfully completed this lesson."

2 insecure direct obj ref

Preventive Mechanisms

Developers can use the following resources/points as a guide to prevent insecure direct object reference during development phase itself.

  • Developers should use only one user or session for indirect object references.

  • It is also recommended to check the access before using a direct object reference from an untrusted source.